9 Comments
User's avatar
TreNesha S.'s avatar

Wow. This was a lovely read about Whistler. I love what you said about counting forward instead of counting back. There's so much talk about the "big" choices in life. Where to go school, when to get married, when to have kids, what career you'll do. And how those "big" choices can shape your entire future. But literally any choice you make can be the one that changes not just your life, but the life of anyone who comes after you. I met my husband because he sat behind me in freshman class. A seating chart determined the bulk of my future. It seems crazy to think about. And Ann Patchett captured that feeling perfectly in that speech.

Charlie Grimm's avatar

Thank you so much for reading it and for the restack, TreNesha! My favorite part of this essay has been watching everyone find their own version of Eddie's toast in their family.

Eli Carr's avatar

A beautiful tribute to a book I loved. Tom Lake is wonderful, too, but I still need to listen to audiobook.

Charlie Grimm's avatar

Thank you, Eli! We're in the same spot, I'm on the library waitlist for the Tom Lake audio right now.

Sophie E's avatar

Another truly wonderful journey through a book that I simply must read as soon as possible. I can't tell you how much I enjoy reading your thoughts about books.

I loved this line: "people who have jobs and allergies and opinions about cilantro" - that really made me chuckle because the cilantro (or coriander here in England!) debate is such a big one (I hate the stuff).

It got me thinking - only going back to my parents so far; they met when my mum was working as a hotel receptionist. My dad was away on business. The rest is history. But imagine if my mum wasn't on shift that day, or my dad had stayed somewhere else? It almost doesn't bear thinking about!

Brilliant read, thank you for sharing.

Charlie Grimm's avatar

Thank you, Sophie! A hotel front desk and one business trip is such a perfect Whistler accident. Do your parents still tell the story of how they met?

Priya's Pages's avatar

This is such a lovely reflection, Charlie! I'm so glad this book resonated with you so deeply. I listened to the audiobook too, and I loved Ann Patchett's narration. Tom Lake is a great next choice, and Bel Canto is my favorite of her books if you haven't read it yet!

Charlie Grimm's avatar

Thank you, Priya! I listened to Bel Canto, and it grabbed me right away and kept me interested the whole way through. I also loved The Dutch House with Tom Hanks narrating. Have you listened to that one? Tom Lake is next. I'm on the library waitlist for the audio, since it didn't stick for me in print and I want to try again with Meryl Streep narrating.

Priya's Pages's avatar

I have not read The Dutch House but I want to. I read Tom Lake and enjoyed it, but I've had so many people tell me the audiobook is amazing, so I think that is an excellent choice!